Why Different Simulation Types Exist
Hydronic HVAC systems contain pumps, valves, emitters and thermal masses that interact dynamically. No single simulation type covers every aspect of system behaviour.
A dynamic simulation captures time-dependent behaviour: how flows, temperatures and control actions evolve minute by minute.
Imposed load simulation (ILS), on the other hand, applies predefined loads to evaluate how the system responds under simplified operating conditions. Each method provides valuable but different insight depending on the design question.
What Dynamic Simulation Reveals
Dynamic simulation models the real sequence of events in a system:
- fluctuating outdoor conditions
- changes in occupancy
- pump modulation
- slow temperature rise or drop due to thermal mass
- control feedback loops and overshoot
This makes it ideal for verifying comfort performance, control strategy robustness and transient behaviour. Engineers use it to check how the system handles real-world disturbances, such as recovery after night setback or sudden demand spikes.
When Imposed Load Simulation Is More Useful
An imposed-load model focuses on how the hydronic system behaves when heat or cooling demand is specified directly, instead of being determined by control loops or dynamic conditions.
The practical value of this approach becomes clear in imposed load simulation, where the focus is on system capacities, temperature regimes and hydraulic responses under controlled load scenarios.
It allows engineers to:
- isolate hydraulic issues without control behaviour interfering
- check if components can deliver required power
- verify temperature levels across circuits
- detect modelling mistakes before running full dynamics
In many early project phases, ILS provides fast and clear feedback.
Choosing Between the Two Approaches
The distinction between both methods is outlined in RTS vs ILS.
A simple rule of thumb helps:
- Use dynamic simulation when investigating behaviour over time, such as stability, comfort, control performance, thermal buffering and system start-up.
- Use imposed load simulation when checking steady-state temperatures, circuit performance and whether the hydronic design can physically deliver the required heating or cooling power.
For complete system design, both methods complement each other rather than compete.
FAQ: Dynamic vs Imposed Load Simulation